Mac studio fix Concealer vs Bobbi Brown Creamy Concealer

Hello people,
Sorry I've been absent for so long I'm currently trying out products and got sick.
But I've been using Mac and Bobbi brown concealer for a year or so. They take awhile to finish up, especially the Mac one
I have had it for so long and I still haven't hit pan of it, it's seriously packed with so much product! Which is a good and bad thing.
The good thing is that I get my money's worth, the bad thing is that I'm not the biggest fan of it. It's not so bad on covering blemishes but in the eye are I find it dry and too dark.
Bobbi brown concealer is probably by far my favourite (from all I've tested out). It's superrrrr creamy and glides on nicely. I love it so much under the eye.

In the picture I put on my left eye Bobbi brown and on my right eye Mac
As you can see the eye with Bobbi brown looks bigger and more awake, there is more light.
The eye with Mac it looks smaller but it does conceal the dark circles well.
I prefer using Bobbi brown because of it's creamy consistency it's not on the cheap side thought, it costs I think around 25$? I'm not too sure on this I bought mine when I was in the states but I would repurchase it.

Regards,
Yara